Monday, November 10, 2014

Saving a Grace for FCB Management


The revelation of huge shortage at Nganglam FCB Depot has shown how naive FCB management has been all along.  The management had always carried that air of fixed superior notion that they could not be budged from them. Almost always, they attempted to gain ascendency over others by force rather than finesse and always placed exaggerated importance on not showing weakness until this very moment.

Willful ignorance of the  evidences,  misrepresentation of the facts and suiting their own biases now seem to go against their own calculation. The case against FCB are too many now. While ACC has already started to  dig  old bones related to FCB CEO’s corporate misgivings and complete abuse of power, court at Phuentsholing on other hand has edged on its age-old wisdom by making FCB pay for its corrupt practice. The other courts will soon see criminal elements of FCB CEO being exposed even before ACC reveals his misdeeds.

What does all this show? There were embezzlements and shortages amounting to more than 1 crore during present CEO’s tenure. Business  worth millions have been taken off the FCB yard by private entrepreneurs. The question continue to remain, is Bhutan short of educated people to run a company like FCB which is marred with inefficiency, corruption and complete lack of public trust? How did a CEO who has been engaged in corporate misgivings given second opportunity to kill the company? People like FCB CEO is  bent on folly and are overpowered by ambition, anxiety, status-seeking, and face-saving.  All along, he has been overestimating himself of his own strength and underestimating the strength and determination of his adversaries.

He has the habit of twisting facts around to justify what he wants to do. The mind being notoriously apt to play tricks, contrary facts are sometimes forgotten.

No business or company run itself efficiently. It needs a leader who has the skill to perform better and not leave the company in ruins.  Being so obsessed by his feeling of responsibility that he has  lost his grip on reality and has become arrogant... a good man with a forsaken flaws. Arrogance is more dangerous than mere conceit. It was not toward an age of submissive easiness, growing a fatty tissue around values. We need, then, to keep asking questions about our values until we arrive at rock bottom. Building a set of values demands that we go behind the easy phrases of quack reformers and CHANGE BRINGER as FCB CEO claims to be and  look at ourselves as we are and not as we wish we were. Learning the truth will not destroy or impair values that are worth investigating.

The person who operates a business like FCB must have spacious thoughts. Mental near-sightedness of leader and division heads  alike are not only  unprofitable but can  put company and lives of hundreds of employees into risk. There are lot of innocent employees out there who continue to be exposed to  risks and also face daily inconveniences. It is so obvious in FCB today with problem of shortages and embezzlement happening every other season.

This shows how  inefficient and tainted  the division chiefs in FCB are in running the  business units. Part of profitable business like Alu Auction has been sucked out by Damchen while the management  embroiled themselves in corporate politic.

Ethics is the code of values to guide man's choices and actions. These determine the course of his business and of his life. There is no field of human activity in which ideals applied are of more value than in business.

What is the public reputation of  FCB’s  business today?  Public relations do not mean putting up a false front.  

Being a poseur, which means one who gives himself airs, is fatal. Morale is one of the most precious elements in a business. No one will deny the emotional benefits of being one of a group that has high morale, but there is more to it than emotional pleasure. High morale generates thinking and planning, it stimulates initiative and enterprise, it is a most important ingredient of efficiency and only in its atmosphere are people inspired to seek the best. High morale pays off in earnings and job satisfaction, and in the effective operation of business like FCB. Indeed, high morale spreads outward from inside the company. The workers who are happy in their jobs, with confidence in their management and co-operative relations with their working team, will spread their contentment throughout the community, and will win friends for the company. What workers say about the company is a potent force in public relations.

When morale is low, workers  feel no great responsibility for the success of company operations; there is a big turnover of employees and there is excessive absenteeism, the company is plagued by disobedience, slow-downs, unconcern about quality; friction; abuse of privileges and power, and all-round tension that is bad for the health of everyone in the company.  

 

213 comments:

  1. Well thought and well written article. I hope RUB will publish this management article.

    ReplyDelete
  2. FCB management should have been sacked by now. I guess the FCB CEO has been trying to downplay Nganglam embezzlement case.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is quite interesting actually. FCB CEO do not have business background. He only has big and dirty mouth. He do not have good professional support of his division heads like tshering said. Pema Wangchuk do not know his job. he had climbed up the post cos of his Chamcha business. After he fell off CEO's good book, he has neither authority to supervise and monitor depot under him properly nor does he have capacity. similarly, Sangay Wangdi is involved in Chamcha business and making his fat belly fatter by stealing. FCB CEO actually supports thieves because he himself steals from FCB. Kezang SFO is a black hearted man playing safe game. If Kezang SFO and Pema Wangchuk were in talking terms and were working closely, maybe all the theft, embezzlement and shortages would not have happened till now. Personal problems have taken front seat and company works have suffered. I think the Ngangklam problem should be the responsibility of Kezang SFO for not doing proper reconciliation with banks and accounts and also the problem of Pema Wangchuk for no supervision and monitoring. How can FCB ignore bank reconciliation for months and months. This shows, like Tshering, has remarked, the efficiency of FCB management.
    By the ways, the administrative lapses on the part of FCB management as is shown above, will be slapped on FCB again by court as has happened with BBS management team. They all got sacked and I hope FCB goes to court with the issue because ACC has failed to sack FCB management till date. I hope court will sack FCB management for mismanagement and abuse of power.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I can see a complete failure of FCB system now. I have heard about FCB CEO and his goons. I hope we the day will not be long when FCB CEO will hear his names in BBS. I think the things are already unfolding.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have heard that the guy called sangay wangdi steals rice, oil and what not from FCB and feeding his labourers when building house. I think he also used office e hilux to ferry the stolen things.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Looks like some people are having sleepless nights these days. With ACC and RAA on the back of FCB business, it may not be long before someone finds himself looking at ceiling for long time. I am wondering what CEO, Pema Wangchuk and IT people have to say to ACC soon.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I like this para. It is so true abt FCB CEO and his officers,

    "No business or company run itself efficiently. It needs a leader who has the skill to perform better and not leave the company in ruins. Being so obsessed by his feeling of responsibility that he has lost his grip on reality and has become arrogant... a good man with a forsaken flaws. Arrogance is more dangerous than mere conceit. It was not toward an age of submissive easiness, growing a fatty tissue around values. We need, then, to keep asking questions about our values until we arrive at rock bottom. Building a set of values demands that we go behind the easy phrases of quack reformers and CHANGE BRINGER as FCB CEO claims to be and look at ourselves as we are and not as we wish we were. Learning the truth will not destroy or impair values that are worth investigating. "

    ReplyDelete
  8. It is shameful to know that for payment of retirement benefit of staff, the FCB CEO requires the approval of Regional Director, Labour Ministry. Gradually, CEO is putting FCB under Labour Ministry but the staff should be grateful to FCB CEO for his ground work to drag FCB under the Region of Labour as the Head of Labour Region will be much more efficient in managing human resource. It is learnt that more shortages are in line especially with the resigning of the newly recruited Food Division Head.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the FCB is being run by psycho people from what I read here. The author has beautifully portrayed the working condition in FCB through his eyes and I think the Government should revamp companies like FCB as soon as possible to encourage young and efficient people to take stock. From what has been written here, it seems that FCB is engaged in unethical practices which is not good to hear but it is good to note that there are people who can raise voice and make people heard. This is the advent of corporate democracy and we hail it. We look forward to reading the truth n Kuensel and see it in BBS soon.

      Delete
  9. "growing a fatty tissue around values"...this statement is really powerful.

    ReplyDelete
  10. the Nganglam case has come at the right time. This shows what kind of management and supervision we had in FCB for such a long time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If Finance section had done reconciliation in time, this shortage could have been avoided but after CEO started to transfer and people resigning, everything got hotch potch. I think it is time for the Government to realize that getting master degree is not enough to be CEO. You may have to have correct degree with better good reputation and not a liar and self centered CEO like the one FCB has right now. He is flanked by two self centered lieutenants and then one useless outdated JMD. He was long date expired like FCB quota rice.

      Delete
  11. after all these months, its good to hear that some people in fcb will be resting from work now and going for few years meditation at Chamgang. sunny days are over now, and swampy days are coming. hope some IT people, CEO and pema wangchuk are having good sleep and saying goodbye to family

    ReplyDelete
  12. Its good to hear that fcb ceo is now under investigations by ACC formally. he should have been sacked by now. it was a very long wait but it was very much worth waiting for. happy for champay and family who had gone through horrors. at least now we can see that there is a light at the end of tunnel. people like FCB CEO, Pema Wangchuk, sangay wangdi and Jit should have long been suspended but when mafia rules, it takes long shot like tshering to handle people. if this is not done now, innocent people will die under the weight of sangay wangdi and pema wangchuk. now at least pema wangchuk is separated. I was shocked to hear the recorded conversation of pema wangchuk with indian prties. this shows how dirty that guy is. The rice case will keep going up and ultimately in the end, he should go where he belongs, that's Chamgang and alongwith him, he should take CEO and others. Well, done Tshering for all the information you collected and the recorded conversation between pema wangchuk and balajee was nothing short of ACC investigations.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This shows clearly how FCB has manipulated the case. I just can't believe this.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Paw, the recorded conversation is very clear that Pema Wangchuk and indian parties were involved in theft of rice and sugar.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well done Tshering. U now broadcast on the blog and put FCB CEO and Pema Wangchuk to shame.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Well done tshering, the truth has come out now. Make sure that you don't leave any of the bastards. Peel them up and hang them dry in winter sun. Its good that you have published it.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Amen, FCB. the only thing FCB CEo and his party can do is wait for ACC and Audit to spank their ass again. Whoever got the conversation recorded, very well done. And job well done Tshering. I can't believe my ears that FCB CEO was such a mucked up arsehole.

    ReplyDelete
  18. well done. I liked the idea of hearing it live on cloud9 . this is how people should be exposed. Whoever is the FCB CEO and pema wangchuk, they should now hang themselves in shame. what a miserable bstards

    ReplyDelete
  19. I know this pema wangchuk guy. he was involved in many corruptions in FCB from previous MD time. I think his karma has now ripened now after doing evil to many FCB staff. what goes around comes around and now his time has also come. he forgot that at one time he will meet some equal or more strong rival. now his future is hanging in FCB weighing machine. most of the FCB staff are very happy that his time is coming now including FCB CEO to g/o out and bask in court sun shine. I cannot believe that FCB CEO who is educated guy is involved in spreading lies. actually all staff know that he is a liar who boosts too much. now u go and boast to ACC and court.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. this karma has ripened from cheating tashi penjore. this is how God balances everyone's deed. both the fcb ceo and pema wangchuk deserves to be out and stay waiting for audit clearances for lifetime to get job or business. with nganglam case, now I think FCB CEO's contract should be suspended and I hope the government has understood that it is the work of FCB management as tshering has said. if it was monitored and supervised well in time, this case would have never come out

      Delete
  20. I read one paper on FCB CEO at finance ministry. didn't know he had link to this scandal.

    ReplyDelete
  21. government has not approved his extension yet although board okayed. just wondering if someone's contract is finished and not yet approved, then how fcb ceo can come to office and sign papers. isn't that illegal? I asked questions to many other office and I heard, interim CEO usually cannot come and sign papers until contract is formalized?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No surprise. FCB CEO does nothing legally. He is involved in so many illegal things and that's why he is under ACC and audit investigations. Interesting thing about this guy is that he may not be in FCB for long time now.

      Delete
  22. fcb ceo looks like the couch of corruption with skills in corruption practices.

    ReplyDelete
  23. HM's national day message was clear and loud. hope FCB CEO heard it well and had time to digest what HM had to say.

    ReplyDelete
  24. the Chukha court has made clear who is involved in rice case. its good FCB is asked to pay the money to balajee. i think pema wangchuk should now know what he was upto. if you have very crooked mind, this is what happens mena la. all this time, when u were in adm and hrd, you messed up so many people. now ur karma has also ripened and now u see wherever u may go, the burden will always land on ur head. now enjoy making payment for rice and sugar and then so many things lotsa time.

    ReplyDelete
  25. sad for pema wangchuk. even if he pays his whole life, he will still be in mess. what a way to get into a mess. now that court has hinted that he is liable when ACC comes, maybe its about time he thought seriously and made exit gracefully before ACC kicked out everyone including CEO

    ReplyDelete
  26. with court passing verdict against FCB and investigations from ACC, RAA and other institutions happening, it may not be good year for FCB. Even then I want to wish FCB CEO, Pema Wang chuk and Sangay Wangdi good luck for this year because I feel they will be kicked out very soon

    ReplyDelete
  27. the bastards pema wanghuk and sangay wangdi and ceo should be out now

    ReplyDelete
  28. after cheating tashi penjor and many staff, finally pema wangchuk is dancing to his own music. sampa zangna sa dang lam yang zang. sampa ngyena, sa dang lam yang ngyen

    ReplyDelete
  29. FCB CEO knew that there was something wrong with rice case and he deliberately invited ACC to seal his fate. He also knew that Pema Wangchuk was involved in the crime but he refused to take any concrete action. As a result, he invited mess. Now he is trying to advertise in the BBS that he is doing country a favour by meeting targets. He will never tell the BBS that there is a scandal happening under his management. He is very cunning and intelligent but unfortunately, his luck is running out now.
    With Sangay Wangdi as CEO's adviser and Pema Wangchuk as devil, I see FCB CEO's future. I also see Megraj and IT people's future. What a way to commit suicide. What a way to end service.I know Pema wangchuk and sangay Wangdi since long time. Sangay Wangdi, if one checks his history, he may have never attended college like any regulars. I think everyone of his time knows including his ex wife Choning Delma.
    Pema Wangchuk, poor bastard, he bought the problem for himself. Someone is right about Sampa Zangpo. This is the fruit of all the manipulations, cheating and unethical practices. Now when outsider like Tshering Dorji catches you by the neck and drags you all the way to ACC and court, you will see all your past misdeeds.
    Now it is a simple choice for CEO also. Resign gracefully or wait for ACC to kick you out. You will do FCB a great favour if you resigned on moral grounds. That will give you dignity.

    ReplyDelete
  30. FCB CEO is very good in arm twisting the truth and therefore will not agree to resign gracefully as suggested. We are longing to see him kicked out gracefully rather. Now with the disputed rice shortage of Shampay if the verdict is to be paid by FCB, CEO and Sangay Wangdi must be made to pay because the main driver Pema Wangchuk is already penalized by CEO administratively. One cannot be penalized twice on the same case as per the law of the land. Any one knows about Nanglam shortage? we concerned citizens are interested to get some update on it.

    ReplyDelete
  31. i don't thinking administrative penalty will justify pema wangchuk's corruption case. the chukha court has made it very clear during the hearing that FCB has deceived the government. the drangpon also was said in the court room that ngawang jigme may not have been passing the message of the court to the FCB CEO. the drangpon already hinted that the case at the moment was about payment to balajee. balajee had appealed of to the court of non payment by fcb. pema wangchuk in his letter to fcb ceo has accepted receving rice and without authority has converted the rice. the case looks straight here and that's how fcb requires payment to be made. other way round, how did so many documents appear for the same rice? why did fcb ceo lie to customs officials? where did rice go? if ice had come to fcb, why didn't pema wangchuk account in the books of accounts? while labourer have submitted that champay has received rice and asked them to convert to 551, pema wangchuk has submitted that he had asked for conversion and in between 30 tons of rice was lost. why did megraj change statement? how much money did he receive for this? all these is coming soon from acc. this case shows very very clearly that FCB CEO, pema wangchuk, megraj and balajee were involved in theft of rice and also in implicating someone innocent. so until ceo, pema wangchuk and megraj are put behind bars, just making payment will not satisfy judgment. they should be out into the street.

    Sangay Chophel, Independent Attorney, Thimphu

    ReplyDelete
  32. if ceo is to resign gracefully, he would have done when nganglam case started. he is waiting for acc n court to send him out without benefits

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha...yes he is really clever ..

      Delete
  33. no rule is applicable to ceo, rules are bent at the whim of karma ngidup. To cite example from many, he claims to have wonderful fcb service rule and as per the revised rule, grade 6 are designated as Dy. General Manager and gr 5 as General Manage. Despite such nomenclature clarity, people in grade 6 are re-designated as General Manager. Shame on CEO for not following the fcb service rule which he always claims as his baby. Let it not rot anymore. The concerned authority should do something before the corrupted ceo damages further.

    ReplyDelete
  34. As one of the oldest companies in Bhutan, FCB should have taken lead role in not only providing food security during crisis but should be been relevant in day to day lives of the people by helping curb inflation. FCB as an oldest company has assets and infrastructures which is built to fight these forces. Unfortunately, the FCB management instead of bringing about positive changes and reforms got involved in corrupt practices. This is a complete waste of Government resources. I think there is a need for Government to review the existence of FCB itself because now there are so many companies and private companies who can do better business than FCB. Food security can be managed by Office of Disaster management.I think they will do professional business than FCB. There is no need to worry about the staff and officers in FCB. They are expert cheaters, liars and thieves. So they will not go hungry. In fact the 2nd man in FCB, Sangay Wangdi and Pema Wangchuk, current RM of SJ, are expert thieves.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, the CEO himself is a liar who lied to Customs Officials during the meeting. The minutes of the meeting with Customs Officials show that. Such kind of CEO is running FCB now and people can imagine where FCB is headed

      Delete
    2. he is also a cheater and thief. he cheated the board of directors about his salary and also bought new duty prado landcruiser. he also cheated fcb and pocketed discretionary allowances for two years

      Delete
  35. Oh I thought he has pocketed the so called discretionary fund for three years. Was it for two years? Good there is atleast some saving for FCB whatever the amount may be and also since by not pocketing for the 3rd years proves that the earlier two years pocketed discretionary fund was wrong, he might as well come forward to refund. He is after good at mouth not heart but.

    ReplyDelete
  36. 1. FCB CEO purchased new duty Landcruiser during the time when Government issued total ban on import of vehicles . FCB already had duty Landcruiser donated by WFP then and why the FCB CEO purchased new landcruiser is not known.

    2. The old landcruiser donated by WFP is not used for FCB official duty. FCB CEO has been using two landcruisers for his duty and for the last three years.No one knows who has been using the landcruiser.

    3. FCB CEO has pocketed Nu. 210000 from discretionary grant. Discretionary grant, as the name suggests, should be used to making donations and helping the cause of the society. However, it has been deposited in FCB CEO’s personal account for the last two years. If government money is not spent, it should remain in government account and not in CEO's ac.

    4. The FCB CEO has been increasing his salary at his own whims. When FCB floated invitation of application of FCB CEO, they floated his salary as Nu. 50,000. Later when this CEO was appointed, his salary was revised to Nu. 60,000. Later on the pretext of changing the service rules, he increased his salary to 70, 000. Service rules were endorsed by Ministry of Labour in 2013 September. However, he started to withdraw revised salary from 2013 January. Now his salary is Nu. 85,000. We are of the opinion that salary of all staff and the CEO once appointed are being sent by Ministry of Finance.

    5. While the Finance Ministry guidelines clearly says that the bonus should not be above two months, FCB management has paid bonus above two months knowingly without regard for the Finance Ministry guidelines. Similarly, Position Specification Allowances are being paid to his cronies and not to others.

    6. FCB management is involved in manipulating the stock inventory system. The FCB management was involved in manipulating the stock inventory system by using the IT department. They were caught by outsider doing it and as such, they are now under ACC investigation for manipulation of the stock inventory system and implicating innocent people.

    7. FCB management is also under the scanner of Regional Employment and Labour Office for misusing authority and abuse of power. They have been fined many times by the RELO.

    8. FCB management has also been involved in making fake documents and customs import documents.

    9. FCB CEO has been abusing the power by making security guard cook his meals at his house. Mr. Pathay, who is on FCB pay roll as security guard has been cooking meals for FCB CEO for the last three years. Further, FCB CEO has been using other security guards to look after his pet dogs, feed them and take them for walks, clean the dogs’ mess. We remember a time where Dagana Dzongdag had to sacrifice his service for using maid and the Dzongkhag made payment.

    10. Under the present CEO, an amount in excess of Nu. 1.3 crores are either embezzled or has run into shortages. The most recent case is related to Nganglam FCB Depot where the in-charge has siphoned off in excess of Nu. 76,00,000 and have died. The problem had happened because of inefficiency of the FCB management, lack of supervision and complete lack of business ethics. Since this is not the isolated case and many such incidents has happened in FCB during this current CEO’s time, it is being felt that FCB is being run by inefficient person who lacks complete business ideas and is also involved in corruption.

    11. FCB management is also involved in favoritism and nepotism cases. He has been involved in terminating the staff he don’t like personally and then favouring those whom he likes. For example, some of the staff who are involved in corruption has been promoted instead of terminating them while those found innocent by the court had to leave office because of harassment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes employees are harnessed and threatened by ceo......he is psycho he changes his decision now an than..

      Delete
  37. Hellow,
    Anybody heard of SEVEN CAMERAS?????
    I heard that ceo had ask the Accounts person to make the payment NU:90000/-.....But the camera are missing...GUESS WHAT???

    ReplyDelete
  38. Plus he teaches administration how to complete the purchase formalities by collecting three tenders from the firm he orders the purchase of his resident king size sofa and office tables and chairs. The sofa were costing Nu. 90000/- plus and tables and chairs claims to make uniformity were ordered from one firm and advices the admin to hunt for three tenders. See how corrupt he is, find out the total cost he invested in his office residence, one will be alarmed to know the amount of investment he has made during his tenure.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Mr. Karma Nidup being a low self esteem man given a post which demands people from relevant background to carry out day to day activities. FCBL is not the best place for people like current CEO who runs the organization with full of guilt of his inefficiency lacking managerial skills and pretending to know everything in front of others. He will definitely fail if someone ask simple question and make him to answer. He is a liar, selfish, corrupt, and self-boasting creature trying to find self-heaven in FCBL with self-made perks, furnished bungalow, two expensive BG vehicle, pocketed three years discretionary amount directly transferred into his bank account, a permanent cook paid by FCBL, and so many things. He runs FCBL with three service manual, the one exact copy given to MOlHR (which is original) is kept in his office locker, the other fake where he manipulated many clauses meant for old staff prior to his joining FCBL and the last one is for newly recruit employees. An interesting thing is with the last one which I believed he had given a copy to HR GM to implement but totally contradicting with labour act and also not same version given to labour. His dirty plan is to create fear in the mind of un happy employees because of his dictator kind of leadership but he manipulated clauses and came out a bond written in Dzongkha because the legal assistant who is just a mouth piece of CEO who forgets what is legal or illegal when his Psycho boss orders him. The bond which actually contradicts with labour act probation clause but FCBL CEO knowingly violated by making newly recruits to sign and even did not provide a bond copy to the newly recruited employees. The labour act says during the time of probation period (180 days), if an employer is not happy with the performance of employee, the employer has right to terminate or cease the contract after giving seven days’ notice in writing and same procedure can also be followed by an employee if he/she is not happy. The selfish man Mr. Karma Nidup, CEO made legal assistant to prepare bond which says "An employer has right to terminate or cease the contract with employee after giving 7 days’ notice period during the probation period" but when it comes to employee's right it reads" If an employee wishing to leave company within the period of three years, he or she will be made to refund three times of salary and other benefits". Where is the right of Employee in this case as given in the labour Act? The right of the employee is taken over by Mr. Psycho Nidup. It was also learnt that he did such an unethical to retain good people in FCBL. Is this a strategy of dynamic leader? There is no issue of people leaving FCBL and they have been with FCBL for last many years as regular employees but they are compelled to leave due to short sighted leader Psycho Karma Nidup. Almost 40 to 50 staffs left FCBL during the tenure of last three years not because they are not happy to work in FCBL but due to abnormal character of CEO. Just wondering, how this man got second term despite so many cases under investigation and most recent one is Nanglam Depot Manager who expired but found misused of around 76 lakhs. This is also due to Mr. Karma Nidup who transferred the manager from Khangma without studying his capacity and capability. All the fund shortages and current problems with FCBL, Mr. Karma Nidup shall be held responsible.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Uh ha! the Karma Nidup has become so unpopular in the town that even his own shadow do not agree to follow him. Inspite of this, did he get the extension?

    ReplyDelete
  41. WHY IS KARMA NIDUP STILL RULING FCBL??? His contract has expired .He is no more MD of FCBL. He should not be seen in office until he renew his employment.His instruction / His signatures are no more valid.....

    ReplyDelete
  42. ACC please ensure every bits and information be properly verified and studied before releasing your report of current investigations. Everyone is eyeing on your report and waiting for the truths prevails. Don't depend only on old vouchers, bills. challans and system inputs. Firstly, properly validate the report submitted by FCBL management. Check any conflict of interest prevails and also refer audit draft report and final report. Seek clarification and doubts from the committee members with the conditions otherwise getting the truth will be very difficult. Now ACC can also call all the committee members including CEO one by one and interview and note their points and compare. If found any differences then compare all the differences and those mismatch of differences will lead you to get the fact and truth answer. This is one of the many ways you can catch FCBL CEO and make him accountable for all the problems in FCBL.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Without clear direction from the Government, the CEO should have stayed away from the office. Anyways, I heard he is a shameless guy being assisted by a shameless thief. So no wonder they are still hanging around without a slightest shame

    ReplyDelete
  44. Here are some of my observations as staff of FCB. This may go to the Chairman, FCB soon.

    1. Even when Sangay Wangdi didn't have the power to give credit facilities for over 20 lakhs, on what basis did he give credit in excess of 20 lakhs to the suppliers?
    2. Even after the ex-MD Kinzang Namgyel ordered for Sangay Wangdi's termination, people like Karma Chindu and Singye Sir pleaded on his behalf and moved him to non functional department. As the new CEO was appointed, Sangay Wangdi was given promotion and moved to important post despite the knowledge that he was involved in criminal activities.
    3. Even after many years, the credit extended to people like Achalal has not been recovered yet. Instead of making Sangay Wangdi pay for his mistake, FCB CEO is planning to put up to the board for write off. If this is to be done, then all the cases should have also been written off by now.
    4. Forget about Sangay Wangdi being a creditable person, his qualifications and history inside FCB is not only dubious but also marred with lot of suspicion.
    5. The documents presented by Tshering to Phuentsholing and Chukha court has shown clear sign of corruption by Pema Wangchuk and yet FCB management decided to go to court without punishing the guilty ones. This shows that even FCB CEO was involved in corruption.
    6. How come that the white landcruiser were never used for FCB duty after Karma Nidup came into power? Whose landcruiser is it?
    7. How come that business like JPLP and Tashi are doing very well while FCB's super market is now out of business? This shows the efficiency of FCB management.
    8. How come that the FCB management has lost so much money in embezzlement, shortage and corruption and yet the balance sheet of FCB is showing huge profit?
    9. How come that the service rules of FCB are manipulated again and again?
    10. How come that the FCB management is using people like Sangay Wangdi, who is corrupted, to manage FCB on his behalf?

    ReplyDelete
  45. Sangay Wangdi was under the scaner of ACC during ex-MD Dasho Kunjang Namgyel. But soon Karma Nidup joined, ACC was brain wash by leg and arm twest of Karma Nidup. Sangay Wangdi came back clean and Langa to handover the charge to Sangay wangdi who was looking after only the WFP office because of the magnetic power of corruption of Sangay Wangdi..

    ReplyDelete
  46. Provided ACC takes longer than the usual time to complete FCBL's investigation, then one has to suspect there is conflict of interest between FCBL and ACC. One should relate the history of Karma Nidup's past employment (Ministry, Department and Division) and see any leaders in ACC have the power had worked or happened to be in same ministry, department and division with CEO of FCBL. By going the duration of case which has serious financial implications and huge loss for the nation looks to be taken very lightly by our high regard Office Anti Corruption Commission. Once more, I like to inform ACC that people are eying for your report to come out with truth based on concrete evidence not based on background and power. The nation is not expecting Karma Nidup to let free by your esteem office.

    ReplyDelete
  47. Actually everybody knows who are involved in the theft of sugar and rice. When the case first came into limelight, Champay and son had put labourers in police custody. Sangay Wangdi and Pema Wangchuk took them out. So why did Sangay Wangdi and Pema Wangchuk take the labourers out if they are not guilty????
    How did pema wangchuk create many customs import documents? how did sangay wangdi brainwash FCB CEO and make jit adjust the computer data from back end? Now the time to explain all these are coming and this cunning FCB CEO should now leave FCB so that FCB's name is glorified again.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yea, that is known to everyone not only in FCB but in whole phuentsholing. everyone knows sangay wangdi's history at auction yard. if someone can bring one person who speaks good abt sangay wangdi, I will give nu 5000

      Delete
  48. Please deposit Nu.5000.00 to my account No. `1112068774500 as the following are the good works about sangay wangdi.
    He steales and asks money from contractor. I was informed the contractor gave him Nu. 25000/ during the errection of fcb main gate signboard. We feel pity that he is now given the charge of purchase department, he will ruin fcb within 6 months. look at the balance sheet after six months.Sangay Wangdi, you go either hell or quit fcb, people talk lot of shit about you. Do not want to go through this web, totally fed up alwaays talking talking not stoping about your name.

    ReplyDelete
  49. FCB old MANs are bullshit... dont have there proper qualificationsssss.. i just hate seeing and ruining FCB... all senior Manager aren't got proper education.... fake FCB OLD MANs

    ReplyDelete
  50. I think HRD Head and SFO have MBA degrees but people like sangay wangdi and pema wangchuk, I am doubtful too. they cant even write one decent letter also. just wondering if they graduated also

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That was one of the reason why sangay wangdi has to depend on class 8 employees because class 8 english is much better than sangay wangdi, so imagine the quality of the head of fcb.

      Delete
    2. Paw, what a shame to know that. How did FCB find him??? anyways, history shows that only rejected people were employed by FCB

      Delete
  51. why old MANs reached ceiling post because they don't have proper education/qualification

    ReplyDelete
  52. Qualification doesn't make any difference.... any Tom, Dick & Harry posses qualification isn't it

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. for people in FCB u need criminal qualification more than academic qualification

      Delete
    2. Yes, that's right. Only people with criminal background rise up. For example, Sangay Wangdi, Pema Wangchuk, Sonam Choden and Ugyen Chedup got promoted. Similarly, CEO got extension for all criminal activities in FCB

      Delete
    3. Everyone in Phuentsholing and Jaigoan knows about sangay Wangdi, Pema Wangchuk and Ugyen Chedup. Ask what they do and people will tell you what they do

      Delete
  53. Good news for FCBL employees. Very soon, your one and only obstacles in the lives of all will bid good bye. Most probably this Psycho Nidup the liar who pretends to know everything but his inefficiencies created mess in FCBL since he took over the role of CEO. He has the quality to polish Board of Directors and tells lies when he presents reports. He has the habit of making people to change and edit reports that he thinks it will bring negative aspect. If ACC do the investigation fairly, this Psycho Nidup will not find place to walk freely rather he should put in a separate cell and lock up. Anyways, he will be replaced by new CEO and also there will be replacement for the current empty vessel and dummy who has been given the role by Psycho Nidup to look after FECD, the core business of FCBL. This empty vessel who also claim to a degree holder from no college with BA is happily trying to act smart in front of other genuine degree holders in the Department. Out of 100 percent, only .000.01 percent like him and Psycho Nidup. Among the likers, one is Mr. Nawang Jigme, illegal Assistant and reporting Officer to his two corrupt masters. These three have done and edited many of the reports submitted to ACC, Audit and Board of Directors. All the fellow Bhutanese, please pray for the good cause of FCBL employees by terminating these three people from FCBL.

    ReplyDelete
  54. It is very shameful for all FCB staff to read all these. I think FCB CEO should resign with dignity rather than being pushed out like these. A person will stay for one term or two term but the company should go on forever.

    ReplyDelete
  55. This is what Tshering had to write in his facebook timelines about FCB

    In the Kuensel today, quality and quantity of school supply by FCB was rightfully questioned. What FCB didn't say in Kuensel is, stocks like rice, sugar, oil and other items just vanish in truckloads from FCB stores. I think I know why our students in remote schools are simply dying from unknown desease. There is a mystery inside FCB wanting indepth study.Hope Ana Jamyang Choeden gets to hear the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  56. Weather one likes or not, all the Psychos of FCB will rule and ruin FCBL for further three more years because they are conducting Dolmai Tongchoe to protect them from their evil deeds and that again out of FCB resources, but the question is with the amount of frustration and tears the affected employees has shed, weather the puja performed could safe these ass holes is yet to be seen. All the best for the Psychos of FCBL.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kuensel also mentioned about the food sufficiency where ACC said that some people were involved in rupee trading by manipulating the invoices. Given the ACC's report and Tshering's documents of two invoices, two customs declarations, this is enough proof to show that FCB is involved in illegal rupee trading. Looks like Pema wa ngchuk, supplier and FCB management is well aware about this. If what Tshering has shown is true, then hope Dolma Tongchoe will save FCB CEO's ass.

      Delete
  57. ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The one sending this ????? message is the one involved in theft of sugar, rice and computer manipulation. It can no other be than FCB CEO, Pema Wangchuk and Sangay Wangdi

      Delete
    2. I saw the main thief in TV two days ago. His boss was not there in the TV

      Delete
  58. The very thief and big boss has no courage to come forward now since enough damaged was made against his name. He knows nothing but must have quietly watched in TV whether his advisor speaks any good about him or not. If his chamcha giri happens to cite his name in some instances, it will be fine if not CEO Psycho Nidup the big boss will not speak to him and also he will start doing bad to other employees. This is true nature of current FCBL CEO and this will only create problem in the organization. Board of FCBL and MoA, Please chase away this Psycho Nidup from FCBL and recruit a new CEO having adequate financial background and good managerial skills. Current dirty minded CEO should put behind the bar because he was and is mastermind of all the problems in the past and current.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the Illegal salary revision of fcb ceo is exposed. When people gets too greedy, this is what happens.

      Delete
    2. I think the latest pay revision circular given by finance ministry has made very clear that both fcb ceo and fcb board of directors have no authority to increase their salary. I think the ACC has noted this very well now.

      Delete
    3. now the things are getting crystal clear that FCB CEO is a fraud. Tshering Deki's transfer has been cancelled twice from auction yard. The reason is very simple. If Tshering Deki is transferred, she will have to handover all the charges including cash to incoming casher. Since sangay wangdi has used the cash, he has been cancelling the transfer of Tshering Deki.

      People know that there is a shortage in auction yard amounting to Nu. 35 lakhs or more. How this shortages occurred, I think only sangay wangdi knows. How all these shortages occurred, only FCB CEO will be able to explain. This shows how efficient FCB CEO is

      Delete
    4. wai inna..... how did u know about the shortage..... azaiiiiii

      Delete
  59. oh its good news when fcb ceo joine he made sangay wangdi as head of auction yard and he took advantage to clean up auction yard income.

    ReplyDelete
  60. karma nidup performance good in 1st year but was because of Indian rupee crises. 2nd year profit went down because of his bad mentality but still on profit and staff given bonus based on performance. His performance was 100% and got full bonus of 2 or 3 months salary. 3rd year, no bonus because of low profit. 4th year no bonus at all. 5th year all corrupt people may land in chamgang jail becasue of bank corruptcy of FCB.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Guess what??? Heard that GM-HRAD and GM- FAD are also planing to quit FCB coz of Karma nidup , Bhimraj Gurung &Sangay wangdi. Seems no good & Qualified professionals are able to stay in FCB. These two double standard phychos are taking all the wrong decisions and later blaming those GMS. Actually everyone had hope on Bhimraj's arrival things will improve in FCB but all in vain,all three karma nidup , Bhimraj& Sangay wangdi are radish of the same field.They are busy making their image in-front of big people to reach higher.

    ReplyDelete
  62. All bullshit! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You better watchout this bullshit guy. He has been busy manipulating many things but looks like his luck is running out now

      Delete
  63. disgruntled fcb staffs complaining abt thier bosses ... funny

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you are the only one who is happy about the boss because you are enjoying as his chamcha. You probably are the one who is involved in stealing sugar, rice and stealing money by manipulating computer system and because you are enjoying the good relation now, you are okay but when ACC comes along and fries your ass, we will come and see you

      Delete
    2. nothing against u or ur friends. i dont work in fcb so no connection. if u hv complaints why waste ur time on line. report to acc mena?

      Delete
    3. no worries, the case is already gone to ACC

      Delete
  64. If we look at Balajee Rice case, it shows how stupid and naïve FCB management had been till date. The letter signed by Pema Wangchuk shows that he has received the rice and no one else in FCB at that point of time knows about the rice. Megraj had given statement saying that the rice had been accepted by FCB again without the knowledge again of others working. So the case is very clear, make Pema Wangchuk and Megraj pay for the rice. Why should FCB pay for rice which never came to FCB???? FCB is a public enterprise and not Pema Wangchuk or Karma Nidup's father's business. Pema Wangchuk and Megraj should pay the money for rice and criminally charged for faking documents.

    Tshering C Dorji

    ReplyDelete
  65. FCB has been run by sycophants like Pema Wangchuk, Ugyen Chedup and Sangay Wangdi since earlier MD time. Sangay Wangdi was involved in auction yard cash manipulations and still till date, money has not been recovered. Instead of making Sangay Wangdi pay for misuse of authority, FCB CEO is thinking of writing off the debts.
    Ugyen Chedup was involved in Tashi Penjor case. Tashi Penjor had won the case against FCB. Instead of removing people like Ugyen Chedup, Sonam Choden , Pema Wangchuk, etc, the management promoted them while victims like Tashi Penjore were forced to leave work.
    Pema Wangcuk was involved in mismanagement and manipulation until Balajee rice case surfaced. He was involved in removing Singye sir from the post of FECD Head thinking that there was more money there. He used his sycophancy and link with Sangay Wangdi to remove Singye Sir and occupy his chair. He had neither experience nor ethics like Tshering said to occupy the post. From the documents that surfaced later, it was very clear that there was so much corruption happening inside FCB. If it were not for people like Tshering, nothing would have come out.
    As far as I know, there is corruption in FCB beginning from top. The CEO has been misusing resources like pool vehicle, discretionary fund, illegal salary hike, misuse of security guards to look after his house and dogs, cook food for him, manipulate contract documents, lie unethically to staff and threaten publicly to staff. The question is, how did this loofer become FCB CEO?
    Which official in FCB today other than Pema Wangchuk, Sangay Wangdi, Ugyen Chedup and Kezang SFO are happy and working satisfactorily? Which official today is thinking of staying and serving for FCB?
    Now court has proven that FCB was involved in cheating. Soon ACC and audit will come again and question. The business will be taken away by private sectors and FCB will collapse under shame simply because government has appointed a loofer like Karma Nidup and he is being surrounded by sycophants like Sangay Wangdi, Pema Wangchuk and Ugyen Chedup. Which among these has good history???? none of them. This shows what kind of boss we have in FCB.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In the list, please include useless guy Megraj gurung also. A grade 4 guy is a burden to FCB now. he has neither power, capacity nor knowledge. he should be terminated without benefits

      Delete
    2. the FECD head who went to STCB did not stay for 1 year also. which intelegent man will stay in FCB? only thieves like pema wangchuk, sangay wangdi, megraj and ugyen c hedup will stay

      Delete
    3. thotray megraj.

      Delete
    4. megraj may probably be the only antique pieces in fcb now....big salary but useless. that's what antiques are mena la

      Delete
    5. Thts a strong point to be noted...if one has a bad record with the company then he shud not be in a high position

      Delete
    6. Guys...u all r too much may... especially on the above points..... segregate personal and professional issues....

      Delete
    7. Guys, u better be careful. Some people in this forum is very hurt here. he is warning you all. You better segregate personal and professional issues carefully, lol like segregating rice from stone

      Delete
  66. Why its taking so long to solve all these ...OMG FCB is ruined .Karma Nidup and groups' heart and blood (Whole body) is full of manipulation,Miss use and all unethical word cannot describe these peoples' deeds.we are worried so much.we are common people working to feed our option less family.

    ReplyDelete
  67. Everywhere else it is same from my opinion.Every management of every corporation is corrupted.Its just that we need someone brave to come forward share the problem.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. but FCB is the champion among corrupted corporations

      Delete
    2. God sees the truth but waits...

      Delete
  68. The corrupt practices and efficient manipulation of truth by Phycho Karma Nidup Bhaini stayed for some time but now it is gradually surfacing out everything and common concern citizen should applaud Mr. Tshering Dorji. Not only the town people of Pling knows about Karma Nidup's cheats but even the government agency like Labour is fed up with him. All the best phychos, you have all my curse.

    ReplyDelete
  69. Loads and loads of curse from 1000 plus employees' dependent, 200 plus employees and from up coming future generation to the karma Nidup ,sangay wangdi. They must be having lots of property which they have theft from FBC at this point of time but wait and watch....god will see , Remember, if you are happy at others cost that means your happiness will not last long, sooner or later at any cost you will have to pay for it.......please stop doing manipulation and double standard activities.

    ReplyDelete
  70. with all these bad publicity, I m wondering if FCB CEO can come out of his house also. if I were him, I would melt in pling heat like salt and butter

    ReplyDelete
  71. Auction yard shortage case is out in open now. So this shows what kind of management FCB has.

    ReplyDelete
  72. From the day karma nidup joined, champay shortage, s/jonkhar shortage, nanglam shortage, now auction yard shortage, many complaints against him. Karma nidup please quit FCB. You are very poor in the management. You have chased away all good people, listens only to corrupted people like Sangay Wangdi. Please give chance to others before you make FCB bank corrupt.You only know how to manupulate service rule and increase your salary. Have some human heart to take moral responsibilities to give way to some good and efficient people. Bhutan is not short of better people than you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You forgot about Samir of Thimphu and Tsheten of Samdrup Jongkhar

      Delete
  73. Karma Nidup is trying to promote a bunch of thieves to higher grade again without proper period of maturity for the promotion.Actually all are his chamchas,inefficient main culprits of FCB. See how he is still manipulating the management of FCB without the legal extension of his employment contract.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. he is capable of doing many things except improve the image of FCB

      Delete
    2. empty vessels make too much sound ;)

      Delete
    3. here is a thief trying to make sense of himself

      Delete
    4. pcha la me, lhipdo dre ... lol

      Delete
    5. shameless people, raising neck again

      Delete
    6. cut da necks tey

      Delete
  74. First the Champay case, then Tsheten case, Nganglam case and now Auction yard case. This all shows how effective FCB Management has been. Now I am seriously thinking how audits are performing also

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Champay case 25 lakhs
      Pema wangchuk stealing rice 5.35 lakhs
      Tsheten case 35 lakhs'
      Nganglam case 76 lakhs
      Auction yard case 33 lakhs
      So the total is above 2 crores. Instead of Karma Nidup out of FCB, he has increased his own salary and pocketed 2,80,000. Furnished his house fully with laptop, latest furniture, two landcruisers as his duty and security guards. I think FCB CEO is the only CEO in Bhutan who gets security services and paid cook.

      Delete
  75. he is the only one who get paid cook and guard.

    ReplyDelete
  76. Karma nidup longsharang he is morenmoo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. pathetic fcb staff ... jealous of ur ceo's perks ... watch ur tongue b4 u say all those filthy words. not every1 can bcom md/ceo. gossipping & complaining from behind is actuallly moremmos.

      Delete
    2. Everyone knows that only one can become CEO. No one is jealous of FCB CEO's perk also. What people here are trying to say is that what FCB CEO is has been doing is illegal and not perk given legally. For example:
      1. Increasing his salary has already been noted by Royal Audit Authority for investigations and it is also reflected in the audit memo. If it were legal, then RAA team will not note.
      2. Despite the fact that one cannot misuse official money, FCB CEO misused discretionary allowances, it is also reflected in the memo and I guess ACC team is now investigating the case related to FCB CEO's discretionary fund misuse.
      3. The cottage allotted to FCB CEO is part of the package but nowhere in the rules does it say that he can have cook which is paid by FCB in the name of security guard.
      4. No CEO in Bhutan is entitled to security guard to look after the dogs especially. There are many CEOs in Phuentsholing like STCBL, BBPL, AWPL, etc. Which CEO's dogs are being looked after by the security guards.
      5. The corruption in FCB is beyond repair now. Instead of taking holistic investigations, FCB CEO has been hiding the truths and suppressing the facts. He has been ;lying around like Tshering said and he is shameless. That's why people call him morenmo.

      Delete
    3. the one supporting FCB CEO here is no other than his biggest chamcha that everyone knows. the reasons why FCB CEO has become so moral less and shameless is because of his company with these chamchas.Some of these chamchas I heard are now going to have tough time soon because their good days are now coming to an ends. we need about few more people like tshering dorji to pluck these people, if it were not for people like tshering dorji, innocent staff like us will never make fcb clean. this is public money and not karma nidup's money. karma nidup has no right to misuse fcb fund, resources and staff like this. this is corruption and people should speak about it openly so that ACC will know what karma nidup is doing.

      Delete
    4. hmmm...i smell something fishy here

      Delete
  77. the guy supporting karma nidup as disguise may not be his chamcha sangay wangdi because his english is below the standard of class vi. therefore rule out him and karma nidups bungalow is at the monthly rent of Nu. 25000.00 but now over furnished. It will be corruption if karma nidup is filing PIT at the old not furnished quarter rent.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. all r in disguise in here ha ha ha ho ho ho - chamchas n dushmans.

      Delete
    2. True, a useless and inefficient CEO, chamchas of CEO, dushman of CEO, everyone in FCB and meeting in this forum. No wonder FCB is not moving anywhere. whatever profit is made is lost in shortages and theft

      Delete
    3. Tshering, I think your struggle and fight is now finally paying. You will hear good news very soon. I heard it yesterday and I think it is true.

      Kezang Samdrup

      Delete
    4. Some people in FCB are going to go "BLUE" very soon. Whoever is the management, this is will open huge scandal in Bhutan now.

      Delete
  78. Let's see how much truth is there in this 'noise'. ��

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. there are more truths than that is suppressed, manipulated and misrepresented.

      Delete
    2. You need to prove it....ACC is around....why dont you give the proof to ACC, they will fix the responsible ones......

      Delete
    3. Proof are inside FCB and that's why ACC is in FCB right now.

      Delete
    4. We do not want any thing except the justice for FCB in whole,justice with the employees rights according to the (Original Service Rule) of FCB not of those manipulated copies.

      Delete
  79. Good chance guys!!! Do not miss a single chance to provide clues and information to help ACC to find the misuse of fund of FCB...It is a FCB's property not Karma Nidup's. You should not leave him.we have a great hope on ACC.Only ACC can fix karma Nidup & his chamchas.

    ReplyDelete
  80. Karma Nidup suppose to be a person of high integrity and morals.How is that he is involve in so much of negative publicity.Could be because of his new formed company.Very sad to know anyways.....!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Karma Nidup a person of high integrity and morals......maybe he was in the past but after he came to FCB and met people like sangay wangdi, Pema wangchuk and Ugyen chedup, he became polluted. With shortage of over Nu. 2 crores, he has left FCB is shambles. FCB may never recover the shortage now and it is likely that FCB may go bankrupt very soon if government refuse to subsidize. FCB is not a new company. It is one of the oldest company in Bhutan.

      Delete
    2. Power, huge money and influence of criminal friend Sangay Wangdi (According to his history) made him forgot all the ethical values and morals, because of Sangay wangdi now Karma Nidup is in thick soup.

      Delete
  81. I don't believe this

    ReplyDelete
  82. Today, not a single person in Bhutan talk good about FCB. Thanks to Karma Nidup and thanks to Sangay Wangdi, Pema wangchuk and ugyen chedup. If karma Nidup had used even 0.0005 percent of his education qualification, maybe all these problem and bad publicity would have been avoided. But there comes a time when people become addicted to power and lose conscience and reason and this is what happens when power falls on wrong hand.

    FCBLeaks

    ReplyDelete
  83. Since ACC is around in FCB, I have the following submission to make;
    1. The FCB inventory system is manipulated. There are two transactions related to sugar that has been removed by the FCB IT people. One transaction relates to 36 tons of sugar inserted factiously on 3rd January 2013 and removed. The day of removal is not known but most probably on 2nd or 3 rd March, 2013. Another transaction amounting to 35 tons of sugar has been removed on 27/28 Feb. 2013. While it is 200% sure that IT people were involved in removing the transaction from backend, it is not yet known who has ordered the removal of the transactions. However, investigations reveal that FCB management were involved because they refused to investigate properly and take appropriate actions.
    2. The manipulation of FCB inventory system is applicable to other items like wheat, atta and maida items also. If ACC investigates the stock inventory of wheat, atta and maida for the month of December 2012 through April 2013, it is very much evident that they have manipulated the stock.
    3. The total rice import by FCB is lesser by almost 250 tons of rice during the year 2012 as compared to the total import shown by RRCO, Pling. From the documents retrieved from Balajee enterprise and FCB, there is a clear indication that FCB management is involved in deflection of rice items which is a criminal offense. The officials involved in deflection of rice is still in FCB as WFP Head and SJ Regional Manager.
    4. ACC may like to check FCB CEO's pay package, FCB's bonus payment for the year 2011-2013, the dubious condition under which FCB purchased his pool vehicle and the utilization of the pool vehicle given to FCB by WFP.
    5. ACC should also check the misuse of resources like security guard kept full time to cook his food at the expense of FCB.
    6. There is also a need for ACC to check the income, PL account and balance sheet of FCB because for the past 3 years, the shortage has exceeded Nu. 2 crores and FCB has shown profit. This shows that the income statement, profit and loss has been manipulated by the FCB management.
    7. ACC should also check the past history of FCB managers and see who have been promoted on what basis.
    It is important that FCB management is sacked and persecuted for his criminal offense. I dare him and I have all the documents to prove that he is a criminal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. tshering, u forgot discretion fund misuse of Nu. 2,00,000 plus PSA which is not admissible.

      Delete
    2. KARMA NIDUP'S PSA 18000/- PER MONTH......

      Delete
    3. So much noise on the forums if everything you have written is correct then why don't you come up with proper documents in black and white so that you will have justice then making a noise..... "God see the truth but waits" so just calm down everything will be finalize soon and criminal will be punish..Sometime Little knowledge is dangerous so think before you speak..

      Delete
    4. black and white is there in FCB. Just show it to ACC and they will tell you

      Delete
    5. Had there been black and white the case would have been already solved...LOL..Acc need not have taken so much time..so dun lie Tshering..

      Delete
    6. Good for you, keep believing in yourself. You should have remembered that the Gyelposhing case took some 3 years to resolve. If you are still ignorant, please read through past newspapers.

      Delete
    7. Tshering,
      First try to see your own house..People don' see fire in their own house but can see the smoke of other houses. Have you ever try to find out how you dad Mr. Champay used to do his day to day work in the Office. Are you with him in his entire job service in FCB? Have you inquire about his daily job. If your dad is not quilty and if he is cleans then why doesn’t he come forward for his explanation? Dragging innocent people in the circle doesn't give you justice.

      Delete
    8. Why do you want to hide you name in anonymity in the first place? If you have clear conscience, reveal your name and speak out openly first. I am not looking for justice here. None of the people in this forum can give me justice. I have not dragged anyone into any kind of problem. I have just expressed my concern. My justice will come from the court. I know my father and as a corporate employee for the last 16 years, I also know how corporate business are being carried out. Coming from business background, I know how purchase effects sales, how data are inserted in computer and how correction, deletion and addition are done. I also know how FCB management and probably you also, were all the time doing unethical issues. By putting someone in problem, FCB management cannot afford to sleep in peace.
      Another thing is, I don't have to be with my father 24 hours a day, 365 days a year to know what he was doing. For 37 years of service, if there was any problem, the auditors would have pointed out. There are three audits happening in FCB in a year if you are not aware. One is internal audit, statutory audit and RAA. If you are not involved in this case probably you probably would not have written this accusation. Anyways, if you are trying to save your ass and your boss's ass, all the best. Karma ripens like apple ripens in its own time. I am sure we will have opportunity to meet each other soon. Until then, have great day.

      Delete
    9. Oh My God!!U seem to know lots of thing!!May be you are responsible for the shortages,data correction,deletion and addition as per what you have written above.
      And one more thing..u cant blame anyone in anonymity as well,if you know the name then pin point it..Don't forget you are bluffing in anonymity too.
      Well about not having to be with your father for 24hrs,365days,which also means you wont know that probably the shortages are because of his negligence as being the Overall in-charge.Remember in the circle of suspects you are included as well since you were found roaming around the Go down several times.And for having opportunity to meet each other , I am not interested.You being cunning as a fox,knows the weakness of FCB and trying to throw back the case which from my point of view is to be blamed solely to your father.
      Thanks
      Anonymous

      Delete
    10. Poor guy, I pity you now. I can see and feel your nervousness. I can also see that you are going through sleepless nights. It is understandable and was expected. That's why I went to ACC to look for people like you. By the ways, you must be getting fever now with ACC around. There are chances that you may suffer from heart attack and stroke. You may be seeing your future inside the jail drinking some cold phika. This is what happens when people like you become greedy. I know who you are and people in FCB also know where you are typing the messages. Please do keep posting so that we can have some chat before you go away to your future home. After you are gone, I won't have chance to talk to you. I would really be very lonely without having to talk to you.
      And just to update you about the activities in FCB, your colleagues have been very busy these days writing statement to ACC these days. I am sure your turn will also come. If I am guilty, I am sure ACC will also make me write statements, so you can take be assured of their duty.
      In case you are not able to sleep at night, please pour a shot of whiskey and do recite some baza guru. It surely will help. When my family was going through problem all these time for 3 years, we prayed everyday for ACC to come and investigate so that we can get some peace. Now you pray that ACC don't reach you. Happy Sleeping!!!! I want to snore for once now.

      Delete
    11. Dear Mr. Anonymous,

      Like Tshering said just above, why are you trying to hide your name? How much is your qualification? Why is there shortage in auction yard? Why is so many shortage coming to FCB? How and on what basis did you pay money to achalal and why is it not recovered yet? How were you able to cancel Tshering Deki's transfer?
      I think in the end all these questions will be asked to you. And also, there are many questions la. Maybe you are general manager of FCB but people also know you as thief. Actually, except for new HRD GM, all other GMs including CEO is a thief who have stolen money and resources from FCB.
      Here is a proof:
      1. Sangay Wangdi: FCB auction yard shortage of 33 lacs. Achalal case of more than 60lacs, past case of money shortage with Phub Gyeltshen
      2. Pema wangchuk, accomplice in selling of fcb landcruiser to ex ceo, theft of rice with balajee enterprise, involvement in tashi penjor case

      Delete
    12. Oh I am very sorry to inform you that i had the most sound sleep of my life yesterday and never had a sleepless night and why to have one if you are clear of your conscience.
      You sure do know how to make others feel pity on you and others to think that you all are really not guilty.But this trick will not be good enough for ACC
      Never seen a guy as cunning as you are...Just going to ACC to confuse them doesnt make you all seem less guilty.

      Delete
    13. Wow....I can see that this has effected you since yesterday and you came back to tell me that you had great night sleep. Congratulations. By the ways, no thief ever says that he is a thief until he is caught with evidences. That evidence will come soon because the IT guys are now leaking in pants and paper. They cried miserably yesterday, poor Jeet. He should not have listened to people like you. Anyways, your turn may be coming soon because looks like Jeet has mentioned your name and also the case of Achalal and Auction yard canteen are all in line. RAA special team is coming in June. Now I am wondering what you would be doing at Chamgang. I am really bored without anything to do on weekends. So I am thinking of visiting you at Chamgang and talk to you from outside the car. I have imagined everything yesterday night. I could not sleep with all these imaginations ya. I think you were sleeping in peace, without a slightest guilt. Actually, people like you do not feel guilty because you are so used to doing such things that it is normal for people like you to cheat and eat from others. SO mi can understand you.
      Anyways, I am sure you have prepared yourself well. One guy is coming down to Phuentsholing today by 11 am bus and he has something to say about you and your boss to the media and media will be doing their own homeworks for next issues on FCB and I will also do my homework so that I can contribute to ACC's effort of making Bhutan a clean and corrupt free society.
      By the ways, I have reported about Achalal case to ACC and RAA and about your auction yard canteen case also to RAA. Have nice day. I know who you are now because I found your IP address and people also know your level of English hahahaha.....isn't that smart but you still would call me cunning....never mind. Have a great day.

      Delete
    14. Tshering, you are very funny. Don't be so mean ya. That guy seems to be having nightmare. Look at his posts. He is feeling very insecure and shaky. He is trying to show that he is not guilty by letting you know that he could sleep very well although he questions himself if he is clear about his conscience. Tshering, you are one hell of shrewd fox hahahahaha.....cunning I don't know. Anyways, ACC are around so hope everything will be sorted out soon.

      Delete
    15. Mr. Anonymous has gone silent now. Looks like he is also leaking now,lol

      Karma Chunku

      Delete
    16. What happened to Mr. Anonymous. I thought he would have lot to say. Well, I am sure he must be itching to say a lot.

      Delete
    17. Mr. Anonymous, your turn seems to be coming. Hope you have done puja at home. ACC has already detained lotsa people in Pling lo and have also closed lotsa shops. So you better do rimdro at home.

      Delete
  84. author venting his personal grudges against the fcbl management i learnt recently. hope acc will continue the investigation without prejudice. Justice should be for the betterment of system and not to please one or two individuals. all the best acc.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My personal agenda will be meted out in court but the ACC should know what FCB management has done because if someone does not tell what FCB has done, probably FCB management will never let it appear in the first place. By masking in anonymity and siding with FCB management, I see nothing but personal agenda of greasing simply for your own favour. By the ways, FCB is a public enterprise and was established for public services. There are thousands of qualified people out there in the market capable of doing better than what FCB management is doing right now. If FCB management thinks that it is too personal, than maybe he should see what he has done to FCB with 2 crores worth of shortage and the company falling apart. Its just a shame.

      Delete
    2. Your father is said to be one of the person responsible for 31 lac shortage...is it true la?

      Namgay, Thimphu

      Delete
    3. It is 25 lacs and not 31. 6 lacs case has been solved by Pling and Chukha court and FCB got screwed there.

      For another 25 lacs, I had to go ACC because FCB IT people had manipulated the computer system from the backend and interestingly, even when the proof was presented to them, the CEO refused to acknowledge. I had no other alternative than to go there with proof and luckily they have started the case.

      Delete
    4. Thanks for your frank clarification.. Whoever is guilty should be severely punished and that ACC will ensure it.

      Namgay

      Delete
  85. Seems karma Nidup is diverting the ACC teams towards the innocent staff for interview. Innocent staffs are harassed, thrashed and forced to do the illegal work which is against the rule of the organization but which he only is benefited form that and he tries to play safe. The person who fails to support his illegal and criminal thoughts are said to be non- performer. And you know what he says to those victims’ staff that ….hum good…. That is how you should save your job/family for food…. The statement he is making itself indicates that how big criminal he is as a “HEAD OF THE COMPANY” GOD HELP US…!!!

    ReplyDelete
  86. Tshering, you have not mentioned about the security guards who have to look after the CEO's dogs and the amount of money which has been used for furnishing his bungalow at the expense of FCB. This may sound small but nevertheless, it is used for personal purpose and not for the welfare of FCB staff and customers.
    You also missed that the fact that there was manipulation in auction yard canteen where the canteen guy was chased away just to make way for Sangay Wangdi's wife.
    You also forgot to mention about the cancellation of some staff's transfer twice and then there was a huge shortage of money in auction yard during recent audit.
    And then there was a serious case of nganglam shortage which has been suppressed so far by the management.
    You may also like to check the tax things from RRCO because there is a huge chances of evasion of taxes by the CEO.
    This is a public enterprise as you say and everyone has the right to voice concern about the business of a public enterprise. If one brave man don't take stand, cowards, like foxes and jackals will only take sides with who can give them one loaf of meat. People should stand for what they believe and whether personal or not, it is a criminal issue which should be dealt and sooner or later justice should be done.
    There are definitely thousands of capable people in the market and the best should get chance so that everyone, including me, you and the villagers alike should get benefit from the existence of FCB and not corruption

    Samphel L. Namda
    National University of Singapore
    Singapore

    ReplyDelete
  87. Karma Nidup opened one retail at Thimphu for his own benefit, at the flat which belongs to his friend. He furnished the retail flat spending a million ngultrum. Later he changed it to wholesale. It was his own decision no one else. This is a waste of around 1 million, not a matter of joke. Who is going to bear such type of loss?

    ReplyDelete
  88. Samphel and Tshering, did you notice here something? No matter how corrupted a person is, he will always have some followers and I think it is true in this case also. People have written about what FCB management has done and even the RAA has proven that the salary of CEO had been hiked and what not but still people want to show that there is no problem in FCB. This is what we call magic, lol

    ReplyDelete
  89. Replies
    1. Position Specification Allowances, lol.

      Delete
  90. All the FCB employees are planning to have grand party once the Karma Nidup is kick out of FCB......all waiting for the day.!!!

    ReplyDelete
  91. N u r one of them no?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, all the employees of FCB all over Bhutan,families and our well wishers will party....for the victory,desperately waiting .....:(

      Delete
  92. Tshering, the Kuensel has come up with FCB story today. Nothing much is mentioned but I am sure they are now trailing FCB. This is a good news, especially to keep mainstream news on line so that they keep people up there informed

    ReplyDelete
  93. For the celebration, I had plan to contribute the total bonus but because of poor management of karma nidup, no bonus for us hence will share my LTC.

    ReplyDelete
  94. We could see & smell Karma Nidup & Sangay Wangdi getting mad but they are trying to act as if they are fine in front of us.

    ReplyDelete
  95. I can see that people are getting really exited & personal in this forum, please be clear that there is nothing personal. The author is trying to express his concerns and he has the right. Going by the prevailing nos. of cases in FCB and the amount, any laymen will be able to tell that someone is doing fishy things in FCB. FCB is in trouble. being a public enterprise everyone has a right for concern. If someone is against and can justify you are welcome too. we too respect your decision and justification. may be you can open up a new window and take us to a new horizon.Given the platform everyone is welcom to express their concern but try to differentiate personal & official.

    ReplyDelete
  96. These days Karma Nidup is busy torturing and harassing Security Guards in FCB......actually it was from a week i guess. ...May be he is scared of that ACC team might question some of the security guards for information against him,because usually people/higher ranked person have a tendency of ignoring the lower staff while doing wrong thing........

    ReplyDelete
  97. WE WANT JUSTICE..."FOR FCB AND FOR THE EMPLOYEES" Nothing personal everything is official.One way or other its related to FCB....

    ReplyDelete
  98. Now the Kuensel is keeping track of FCB but they are not mentioning anything about FCB CEO and management. They should write stories about FCB CEO so that everyone in the country would know what he is upto

    ReplyDelete
  99. What has happened to our salary arrears?Why its taking so long???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. no money sirji, all finished in sugar shortages, rice shortage, nganglam shortage, auction yard shortage. where is the money now to pay you arrears?

      Delete
    2. You are just bothered of what you will get...what did u contribute to FCB's performance..... Hope you are not one of the free loader or the excess baggage...

      Delete
    3. respected sir,

      m a simple man with less class pass, less salary, less grade but many service years. you are high class pass, more money more grade. I may not put contribution to fcb but also I have not made fcb name come in kuensel and make people feel ashamed like you all big grades. now our friends relatives, outside people always ask fcb corruption. we all are ashamed.i don't understand free loader or excess baggage but 100% sure u all have finished fcb money doing many corruption and politics inside fcb. during dasho tshering wangdi time, fcb was best company. now fcb is worst worse company.

      Delete
    4. Yes,,,,,,, your are right we are ground worker,you may not feel our contribution but without lower staffs contribution you may not have been contributing to your management.You must be loaded with the corrupt money of FCB,you must be one of the chamcha chor of CEO,You must be having the shop run by your wife with theft money of FCB.So you are least bothered about money......but be ready to go to dark room for Chakipissing and Pissing.... ..what have contributed to FCB performance ?recollect yourself?Only chamcha giri and how to manipulate the data and ruin FCB. Think over what have you contributed to FCB......think before you tell others....

      Delete
    5. poor fcb staff. I feel u all are like pig. pig lives dirty and make other people who want to help dirty too

      Delete
    6. Haha you are calling lower staff Pig???? You must be knowing yourself who is the real pig messing the FCB management.....Right under your nose you have made lots of manipulation and played the dirty game and made the whole FCB environment Dirty...Now who is real Pig???You are making mistakes in making payment and trying to pull the innocent people in the court case and harassing unnecessarily....To makeup your shortages you are doing chamcha of CEO......you are making 100 of mistakes to hide your few mistakes.Who is pig we can prove with picture uploaded in the blog......what you all performing in office we have some of the pictures for right time action..

      Delete
  100. when u have khebsang u take alone & when u r in deep shit u blame ur bosses. ppl who have eaten money in millions should be punished whether they be ex-staff, on the verge of retirement or incumbent. acc is there in fcb & soon the real picture will come out. the problem was there much before present ceo joined fcb & the parasites were caught red handed. now they r trying to defend so hard trying to blame the manager. tsssk tsssk

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. if the boss did not eat khebsang like in rice case with balajee, the court will not make fcb pay. if the boss did not eat khebsang, fcb would not have met with ACC.
      if the boss did not eat khebsang, he will not have been transferred to sj office and called to court
      if the boss did not eat khebsang, he would not write statements

      Delete
    2. Yes this is true as per the working shedule.Professional and personal should not be minggled.Those who have eaten in million and enjoyed like a king and when caught dragging innocent people doesn't give justice. It’s like separating stone from rice not a complicate case for ACC to catch a real villain...So we just wish and pray that innocent people should not be harassed and punished. We want just justice nothing more.

      Delete
    3. What is professional for FCB is personal to an individual. There is a thin line here. If the FCB management knew how to separate personal and professional, they would not have got into mess like this in the first place.

      Those people who have eaten millions have built house without loan, spend thousands in drayangs and others. If people are not guilty and if there is no evidence of guilt , ACC will not make IT people write statements and Kuensel will not write in the newspaper.

      Court at Chukha and Pling will not make FCB pay for rice if they are not guilty. No matter how hard you try to justify yourself, it is too late now because at the end of the day, what matters is the evidences in the court and not your justifications.

      The reason why people come online is because they want to voice their concern about the kind of shady business FCB is involved. If FCB had a point, they would have won the case in the court and also the court would have asked the guilty to pay.

      Please stop hallucinating and come alive. Maybe that will happen only when you come to the court being dragged by ACC.

      Delete
    4. no worries la, the newspapers will all be FCB next week so no worries. please buy cap and sun shades to go out to the town because people will be talking about fcb in open now

      Delete
    5. generalizing is not good like 'all staff of fcb' - no justice system in the world had been fair till now & never will be in times to come. evidences can be distorted & people with influence can manipulate the outcomes. whether one was a 'low grade staff' or 'managers' or 'mds' does not matter ... each one has equal chance of being corrupt & influencing others. but there are always honest among them. this corruption business in fcb should be investigated once and for all & all guilty penalized without fear or favour including those who have retired.

      Delete
    6. I think with acc in pling, fcb people have started to get nervous now. some people may be seeing nightmare mo la. the time to now sliiping away

      Delete
    7. Not only fcb people, even business people are on toes with so many shop shutters pulled down. ACC in real action!

      Delete
    8. any update/s folks? why so silent all of a sudden!

      Delete
    9. some people in fcb not sleep for many days lo

      Delete
  101. oiii, who is that person, please write the name tay.. We will see.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You and ur friends in IT

      Delete